Family First ChiropracticFamily First Chiropractic home
Education4 min read

Herniated Discs: What Colchester Patients Should Know

What a herniation feels like, why the scan and the symptoms so often disagree, and the signs that mean you skip the chiropractor and go straight to the ER.

By Dr. Christine Lebiecki, D.C. · August 15, 2021

A calm environment for healing

A herniated disc is rarely subtle. Most people who have one can tell you the exact moment something changed, and can trace the pain with one finger down a leg or an arm.

For the anatomy behind it, start with bulging discs and the disc spectrum. The short version: the outer wall of the disc tears, and inner material pushes through.

What a Herniation Actually Feels Like

The hallmark is that the pain does not stay put.

Back or neck pain is often present, but the defining feature is a symptom that travels along a specific path, usually on one side. A lumbar herniation sends symptoms into the buttock, the back of the thigh, the calf, sometimes the foot and specific toes. A cervical herniation sends them into the shoulder blade, down the arm, into the hand and specific fingers.

This is usually not a dull ache. People describe electricity, burning, pins and needles, a limb that feels heavy or unreliable. Numbness in a defined patch of skin is common, and so is weakness in one movement: a foot that slaps when you walk, a grip that drops things.

The aggravators are predictable. Sitting is often worse than standing. Coughing, sneezing or straining spikes it, because all three raise pressure inside the spinal canal.

If the pain travels into your leg, read what sciatica is and is not, because a disc is only one of several causes. If it stays in your back, start with the causes of back pain.

Why the Scan and the Symptoms Often Disagree

Here is a fact that should reshape how you read your MRI report.

Herniations show up routinely on scans of people who feel nothing at all, and the older the group, the higher the number. Meanwhile, plenty of people with severe, textbook nerve symptoms have imaging that looks unremarkable.

That cuts both ways. A dramatic report does not mean your case is dire. A mild one does not mean your pain is not real, and it does not mean it is in your head.

The scan shows anatomy. Your exam shows function. When they disagree, we treat the person in front of us, not the picture.

What makes imaging useful is correlation: does the level and side of the finding match your symptoms? A right-sided L5 herniation paired with numbness on top of your right foot and a weak big toe is a coherent story. Without that match, the finding may be a bystander.

It is also why I do not rush people to imaging. For most new disc symptoms without red flags, a careful exam and a trial of conservative care comes first. Imaging matters when symptoms are not improving, weakness is progressing, or surgery is on the table.

Red Flags: When to Skip the Appointment and Get Urgent Care

Some symptoms are not chiropractic problems. If you have any of the following, go to an emergency department today. Do not wait for an appointment with me or anyone else.

Saddle anesthesia. Numbness where a saddle would contact you: inner thighs, groin, buttocks, genitals.

Any change in bowel or bladder function. Difficulty starting or stopping urination, incontinence, or losing the sensation that tells you you need to go.

Progressive weakness. Strength declining over hours or days, especially in both legs, or a foot you cannot lift.

Together these can indicate cauda equina syndrome, compression of the nerve bundle at the base of the spinal cord. It is rare, and it is a surgical emergency where the window is measured in hours.

Two more warrant prompt medical evaluation rather than the ER: severe pain after a crash or a bad fall, and back pain with fever, unexplained weight loss, or a history of cancer.

What Conservative Care Can and Cannot Do

Most herniations improve without surgery. The body reabsorbs herniated material over time, and symptoms often resolve over weeks to months.

Conservative care does not push the disc back in and it does not repair the tear. What it can do is reduce the load on an irritated nerve: restoring motion where the spine has locked down, easing the muscle guarding that compounds your pain, and settling a nervous system that has been running in alarm mode since this started. Not every herniation should be adjusted the same way, and some should not be adjusted at all in the acute phase. The exam decides that.

Care should come with a timeline. If you are not seeing meaningful change over a reasonable course, or weakness increases, the right move is a referral for medical or surgical evaluation, and I will make it.

At Family First Chiropractic in Colchester, Vermont, a first visit for disc symptoms is an examination, not a rush to the table. If you are in Colchester and your leg or arm has been buzzing for weeks, come in and let us find out exactly which nerve is unhappy and why.

At Family First Chiropractic our team is here to help. Contact us today.

Or call (802) 860-0382